How the Transformation of Heritage Brands Succeeds

The pressure on heritage brands currently seems higher than ever. A flood of trend brands is pushing into the market via social media. At the same time, many companies are facing strict austerity measures in light of inflation and the economic slowdown. What are the consequences for heritage brands? How do established brands manage to remain relevant, especially for new generations of customers? Christopher Spall spoke about this in an interview with Handelsblatt.
The decisive skill for heritage brands today is the ability to transform without losing their own core.
Tradition - a quality feature?
According to the Duden dictionary definition, tradition is something that has been developed and passed down through history from generation to generation and continues to endure. A heritage brand is consequently a brand whose lifespan exceeds the usual product cycles. Heritage brands have already existed successfully on the market for some time and are characterized by a strong brand identity. They are often consumed for a lifetime and recommended across generations.
Why are the classics among brands nevertheless having such a hard time at the moment?
The influence of social media
Today, brands can test new products on social media and build a community. Those who understand this game can launch new products and brands with a high probability of success.
Chinese fashion giant Shein is leading the way: a new top is presented on social media and made visible via influencers. If the response is good, the goods are produced within ten days and offered for sale online.
New qualities are in demand: testing, further development. And doing so with maximum speed.
Attractiveness beats tradition
Tradition alone does not sell. To remain attractive to their customers, brands must regularly solve a relevant problem for their consumers. Consumers are spoiled for choice: studies show that — from the customers' perspective — 75% of brands could be replaced by equivalent ones. So even more choice isn't actually needed.
In the search for a suitable problem solver in the thicket of abundance, brands provide consumers with orientation and security.
But this search for the familiar is countered by the interest of brand manufacturers in increasing sales. That is why they flood the market with ever more new products, which then vie with heritage brands for the favor of consumers. Brands without a clear monopoly position have no chance of survival in this competition. They get crushed in the sandwich position between the respective No. 1 brand and the private labels and trend brands.
Because especially on the breeding ground of Instagram, TikTok & Co., new trend and private label brands flourish. They relegate traditional brands to the back rows — on supermarket shelves and in the rankings of online retailers.
The principle of natural selection applies: brands without a corresponding margin will be shut down sooner or later — tradition or not.
Sent to the bin:
Vanished heritage brands
Wrigley’s Chewing Gum
After 150 years, it was game over for the classic from 1893. According to manufacturer Mars, customers nowadays prefer gum pellets instead of strip gum.
Vittel
According to Nestlé, the former "in-water" no longer meets margin expectations and was taken off the market in February 2022. The brand was under fire because the groundwater table in the French town of Vittel is sinking. In the future, Nestlé intends to focus on the premium brands San Pellegrino and Aqua Panna in the German market.
Nestea
The brand was discontinued in March 2023 after over 75 years. The reasons were the high sugar content and the hype surrounding influencer iced tea brands like Bratee (by rapper Capital Bra) or Dirtea (by rapper Shirin David). Another reason was the end of the joint venture between Nestlé and Coca-Cola in 2017. Through this, Coca-Cola was responsible for the distribution of Nestea in nearly 50 countries.
Gala Coffee
Tchibo's coffee brand was discontinued. The alternative is being sold under the heritage brand Eduscho at a higher price.
Onken
The yogurt brand, which was sold by Dr. Oetker to Emmi in 2010, was discontinued in 2022. The reason for this was the stagnating growth prospects for yogurt and quark in Germany.
Punica
The cult drink was merely a peripheral player in the fruit juice market segment. And it fell victim to a strategic portfolio realignment following a change in ownership. Farewell, Punica Oasis.
If you don't go with the times, you go over time.
How transformation succeeds
Heritage brands are under massive pressure. On the one hand, they offer security and orientation, especially in times of upheaval. They convey a sense of harmony and — in the face of war, climate change, and economic crisis — the good old days. On the other hand, many new trends are pushing into the market. And the increase in retailers' private labels ensures further selection, as consumers look more closely at prices due to inflation.
Serving these needs while simultaneously solving a relevant problem for today's customers is the task for everyone responsible for heritage brands. They face the challenge of keeping both the brand's DNA and Darwin in focus. In other words: adapting the brand to rapidly changing market conditions in the best possible way based on its own identity.
Heritage brands that follow the 3F strategy have the best prospects of remaining number 1 for their customers, even in fast-moving times.
The 3F Strategy from Spall Identity
Future Focus:
Consistently leveraging megatrends such as sustainability and individualization.Customer Focus:
Keep customer needs in view: Only those who stay close to the customer remain relevant.DNA Focus:
Don't lose your own core: Protect and further develop core strengths amidst change. Show character and win customers as ambassadors. A credible identity is what makes identification with the brand possible in the first place. Brand identity makes the difference.
Brands with history and success
Examples of heritage brands that have managed to accompany customers throughout their entire lives and remain relevant for several generations:
Lego
Even though there are films, series, and computer games today, Lego bricks still look the same as they used to.Ravensburger
The digital learning pen "tiptoi" shows that the toy manufacturer has understood the megatrend of digitalization.Nivea
The blue tin, which has existed for almost 100 years, enjoys cult status with young and old all over the world.Birkenstock
Barbie wears Birkenstock. The inventor of the footbed stands for health and ecology, but with a modern aesthetic.Nutella
The hazelnut-nougat cream has been on the market since 1964 and remains the market leader despite the main ingredients sugar and palm oil being frowned upon today.Haribo
The slogan "Kids and grown-ups love it so, the happy world of Haribo" by the global market leader from Bonn originated in 1930 and was expanded in the 1960s.
It has become easier to be represented on the market, and harder to stay there.
Strong No. 1 Brands:
Our customers' success stories
With their clear No. 1 positionings, these heritage brands are also successful in the long term. We are proud to count them among our customers:
Clicking on the logo leads to the development stories of these strong brands.
Image sources: Photo by Claudio Schwarz on Unsplash & Photo by Pawel Czerwinski on Unsplash
The interview was conducted by Michael Scheppe.
Image source: Foto von Claudio Schwarz auf Unsplash