Gamification in the Marketing Mix: Does it Fit the Brand Identity?

The Hamburg-based start-up Applike develops and markets smartphone games. Founders Jonas Thiemann and Carlo Szelinsky rely on technology-driven advertising. For companies, this opens up new playing fields in the marketing mix. In an interview with Handelsblatt, Fabian Gärtner also points out the (moral) boundaries that should apply to brands with a sense of purpose.
Just because you can make money with something doesn't mean you should.
(...) At the beginning of 2023, Applike opened a sales office in Boston. Since then, the biggest catch Applike has likely landed is Fetch. Fetch is comparable to the loyalty program Payback. In the app, receipts are scanned, and in return, customers receive points and discounts for future purchases.
Through the Fetch app, customers can also install games. The more successfully and the longer customers play, the more discounts they receive.
The benefit for Applike? The Hamburg-based company gets a cut of every game installation in the Fetch app. (...)
Awareness alone is not enough to attract and retain users.
How sensible and promising is it for providers of bonus programs or food delivery services to keep their users in the app longer with gaming options and thus offer them additional points/discounts?
The mobile gaming industry knows exactly how to get users to use their games intensively – and how to monetize them. Whether through in-game purchases or targeted advertising. Applike is successfully transferring this knowledge to the US market. With platforms such as food delivery services, we always observe a winner-takes-it-all situation. The platform that offers the largest range across the board wins and expands its lead. The rest lose more and more attractiveness. And attractiveness is the currency of strong brands. Awareness alone is not enough to attract and retain users. If Applike now manages to increase the attractiveness of a platform with its game integration, the chances of the platform asserting itself as No. 1 in the respective category also increase.
If the plan succeeds, it creates a win-win-win situation:
The usage time of the platforms increases - and thus their chance to prevail.
Applike generates easily scalable profits and brings users into its own games.
In cooperation with Applike, advertisers can play out targeted advertising to suitable users via the games.
Does this business model push economically weak people who rely on discounts to spend their time with mobile games?
How does this affect the perception of the brand?
Should the first collaborations achieve the hoped-for effects in the long term, the attractiveness of Applike in the US market will increase significantly. Success gets around. Other platforms will quickly knock on Applike's door – and other providers of similar solutions will enter the fray.
The benefit of gamification for platforms depends on the target group. For platforms with a young, gaming-savvy audience, this can work well and positively influence the perception of the platform. However, if the target group finds no connection to it, the dwell time in the platforms' apps will hardly increase. In this case, gamification has no positive influence on the attractiveness of the platform. Worse still: gamification can even be harmful to a platform if gaming does not fit the brand identity.
Gamification can even be harmful to a platform if gaming does not fit the brand identity.
Where are the limits of the undertaking?
There are several limits here. On the one hand, the factor of time. The more platforms integrate their own games, the more choice the user faces. And every user only has limited time available. Should the model prove to be sustainably successful, other providers will push into the market and reduce margins.
On the other hand, Applike's success is strongly linked to the success of the platforms. At the same time, the risk to Applike's reputation in the event of platform problems is low, as there are hardly any spillover effects on the brand – because it practically hardly appears.
It is also questionable how many platforms Applike can supply with creative and interesting games.
The other limit is a moral one. If a game on Fetch meets a user who enjoys the game and can still save money without falling into the monetized addiction spiral, everything is unproblematic. However, if such a business model meets vulnerable users who fall into the addiction spiral and spend a lot of money through in-app purchases, things look different.
For users who are economically dependent on coupons and discounts, the question arises: Does this business model push economically weak people who rely on discounts to spend their time with mobile games? Every brand should develop its own stance based on its identity and use it as a compass for all questions between making money and doing good.
Ultimately, the insight remains: just because you can make money with something doesn't mean you should. Every brand, including Applike, must answer this question for itself.
The interview with Fabian Gärtner was conducted by Michael Scheppe.
Image source: www.shutterstock.com/g/fizkes / Stock-Foto ID: 2246712357