"Mia san mia" means arrogance and intolerance - FC Bayern DNA requires a new motto

The message conveyed by the German record champions through their slogan "Mia san mia" is no longer contemporary. In an interview with AZ München, Christopher Spall explains why the traditional club urgently needs to reflect on its core values.
What the motto should convey is not arrogance or intolerance, but what has always defined FC Bayern at its core.
Time and again, former FC Bayern players criticize that the German record champions have lost the "Mia san mia" gene. (...)
FC Bayern: Kane expected to restore "Mia san mia" mentality in attack
Immediately after his arrival, the FC Bayern striker was presented with his new work attire. On it, in bold letters: "Mia san mia". From now on, Kane must embody this club slogan and lead the record champions' attacking line back to its former strength with his goal-scoring qualities.
In recent months, both FC Bayern fans and former players like Bastian Schweinsteiger have criticized that current Bayern players and officials no longer embody the slogan as necessary. "You have to live it. You don't have to talk about it, you have to live it," said the former midfield engine of the Munich team. (...)
The discussion about 'Mia san mia' is actually a discussion about the FCB DNA as a whole and the question of whether FC Bayern has lost its core.
"Mia san mia" did not originate with the German record champions, but in Austria. Even in the days of Emperor Franz Joseph, the phrase was used by soldiers to express their sense of superiority. The slogan only found its way to the German record champions in the 80s.
The players at the time, including Hansi Pflügler, Hansi Dorfner, and Ludwig Kögl, would bawl after successes – in not quite grammatically correct fashion: "Mia san mia, mia san mia, mir san stärker wie die Stier." (We are who we are, we are stronger than bulls). Thus, "Mia san mia" was born at FC Bayern and passed down from generation to generation.
Which FC Bayern players embodied "Mia san mia"?
In the following years, Oliver Kahn and Stefan Effenberg in particular evolved into symbolic figures for the slogan. The 2001 Champions League final against FC Valencia remains unforgettable. In a legendary night at Milan's San Siro stadium, Effenberg brought FC Bayern back into the game – and into the penalty shootout – with his determined goal to make it 1-1.
There, the other Bavarian mentality monster, Kahn, became the hero for Munich. The "Titan" saved three penalties against the Spaniards, securing the club's fourth European Cup in its history.
However, it took until 2008 for "Mia san mia" to become the official slogan of FC Bayern.
Who had the idea for the official slogan?
Ironically, the idea came from Marc Kosicke, the agent of Jürgen Klopp.
Previously, Uli Hoeneß had complained to Kosicke on a flight to a FIFA event that many new signings didn't even know what it meant to play for the club. This prompted the agent to form a working group consisting of everyone from fan shop employees to the head of the youth academy.
Within four weeks, they collectively developed values such as local roots and self-confidence, which the club still stands for today. Kosicke knew from the start that "Mia san mia" would become the new slogan for the German record champions.
As the Bremen native later said in an interview with "Kicker": "The name was certain from the start because as a little boy, I hated it when Bayern came with their 'Mia san mia' attitude and still won in the 90th minute."
Hoeneß and Karl-Heinz Rummenigge were enthusiastic about the slogan. From then on, FC Bayern embodied "Mia san mia," and even coaching greats like Louis van Gaal internalized the club's motto. But years later, it seems the slogan is becoming increasingly rusty and primarily drawing criticism.
'Mia san mia' also means arrogance and intolerance. I believe that no brand in the world today can still afford to communicate ignorance and consider itself something better. Today, it is important to communicate at eye level and take people along with you.
The content that FC Bayern conveys with the slogan is simply no longer contemporary. (...)
What the motto should convey is not arrogance or intolerance, but what has always defined FC Bayern at its core.
This core includes, alongside the family values shaped by current honorary president Uli Hoeneß during his time as manager and president:
To perform especially in pressure situations and not to lose the power of conviction during setbacks. These are the cornerstones of the Bayern DNA. Every player and every fan should actually be able to identify with this club DNA.
Now it is important to live the core values that made FC Bayern an unmistakable club in everyday life and to prove them again. (...)
I suggest that FC Bayern condense this core into a motto, and I believe that would be a stronger platform for identification than 'Mia san mia'.
This is certainly one of the tasks that the bosses around CEO Jan-Christian Dreesen must/should tackle. Whether they succeed in filling "Mia san mia" with (new) life - and then perhaps replacing the motto with something more contemporary?
The interview with Christopher Spall was conducted by Kilian Kreitmair.
Image source: https://pixabay.com/de/photos/fußball-soccer-europe-europa-uefa-2697618/