Three Learnings for Leaders: Authenticity, Clarity, and Emotionality

Olaf Scholz is not seen as a popular or charismatic figure. Nevertheless, he and the SPD are ahead – even though they seemed to have no chance for a long time. In an interview with WELT, Christopher Spall explains the reasons behind this success and derives three learnings for leaders that can boost any career.
1. Authenticity Beats Charisma
How did Olaf Scholz manage to rise so high in the polls as a candidate for chancellor?
We need charismatic people again who are capable of creating a sense of a new beginning. But when it comes to future-oriented topics, we are only mediocre in this country. Neither Scholz nor Baerbock nor Laschet represents a new beginning in the slightest. Three candidates who do not embody what our country needs right now. At the same time, however, we notice that Scholz does not have to be charismatic at all to win over voters. This is also an achievement of the campaign team. They let him be as he is. Boring. That is brave. Because in a campaign, a candidate is usually cast in a certain light. But with Scholz, no one says: 'Hey, Olaf! Maybe try it again with a bit more emotionality.' He is completely himself. And thus, he appears authentic. (...) Ultimately, credibility is the currency that decides at the ballot box. In Germany, it still holds true: authenticity beats charisma.
Why is that?
Charismatic leaders are eyed skeptically in this country. (...) Authenticity is the decisive tool for differentiating oneself among the profile-less and the bores. Olaf Scholz succeeds in this. He does not allow himself to be provoked. He doesn't flinch; he just parries and parries. And because he behaves this way, he is the only one who also appears statesmanlike. (...) He is ahead not just because he is the only one who hasn't made a serious mistake. It is this alignment between self-image and public perception. That works surprisingly well for him.
How did Annalena Baerbock manage to not come across as the spirit of a new beginning?
On one hand, through her own oversights, which overshadow this spirit of a new beginning. When people are only talking about the polishing of a CV and plagiarism in a book, then it is damn hard to get through with your own messages. Then the overall mood is minor key rather than major. On the other hand: the longer this election campaign goes on, the more it emerged in interviews that while Annalena Baerbock can introduce modern topics well, as soon as it gets into the details, she radiates uncertainty. That is poison for building a brand. A brand should provide orientation and security. The human brand has the same task. Uncertainty is the opposite of what one expects from a strong brand. This leaves the feeling that this job is a few sizes too big for her.
And why is Armin Laschet doing so poorly?
He is still associated with that laughter in the flood zone. It is probably even a positive quality not to lose heart even in difficult situations. But his laughter has become a symbol that he might lack the stature for the office. Laschet never got rid of this topic. A personal brand is about the feeling it leaves behind. Now Laschet embodies the feeling of disrespect. (...) Scholz positions himself clearly on the feeling of respect. Not an interview goes by in which he does not emphasize that he wants to bring respect back to society. Respect for life achievement, for work performance, for unions. And what is on the posters? 'Respect for you'. That is the feeling he communicates and radiates. Very consistent, very stringent. And from the very beginning of the campaign.
But you can't attest a clear profile to any of the candidates, can you?
If you examine the positioning of the candidates, all three are profile-less, no question about it. But only one actively communicates a very specific feeling across various touchpoints—posters, interviews, TV appearances. Respect, respect, respect. Much more could be done. In the business world, personalities such as CEOs are profiled not just with a feeling; every candidate is attributed a clear mission and an inner drive—the reason why they are active at all. With our trio of applicants, we only see wishy-washy stuff.
Why is the Scholz campaign so effective?
My team and I have a methodology for measuring the effectiveness of messages, the so-called MIIIKA method. Each letter stands for a specific success criterion. This allows us to measure the effectiveness of messages in percent. We looked at all the posters of the four major democratic parties: the Union, SPD, Greens, and FDP. How well do the election slogans actually work? The clear winner of this ranking is the SPD with 85 percent. Second place goes to the Greens with 61 percent. The FDP follows in third place with 59 percent. The Union is the distant trailer at 47 percent. This means that only the poster campaign of the Social Democrats is making a relevant contribution to electoral success. And the weak value of the CDU/CSU reflects the lack of profile of both the party and the candidate. The SPD, however, has done an outstanding job.
2. Clarity: Get to the point in a single sentence
What exactly did the SPD do right?
The messages on the posters are: 'Respect for you', 'Vote now for 12 Euro minimum wage', 'Vote for Chancellor for secure pensions', 'Scholz tackles it'. The statements stand out due to high memorability and a clear benefit. They are easy to retell. Bottom line, the posters communicate a clear reason to vote for the party. (...) Basically, it's about what we learned from the whole Trump era: Get to the point in a single sentence. 'Make America great again', 'America first'. But if you need three sentences or a sentence with a comma on the election poster without a clear message, then you won't succeed in activating the voters.
Does it help Scholz that people associate his manner with Merkel?
The Scholz type has great similarities with the demeanor of Angela Merkel. That calm and composure. What people certainly appreciated in Merkel and what increased in importance during the pandemic. Olaf Scholz reminds people of these qualities with his almost indifferent appearance. (...) Laschet simply does not embody this calm, composure, and competence. Scholz does. Markus Söder attributed a 'Smurf smile' to Scholz. Well, that Smurf smile could become a winner's smile on September 26th.
3. Emotionality: Truly emotional people will be the leaders of tomorrow
Can employees, self-employed people, and bosses take away something for their own success from these factors?
Authenticity before charisma. Everyone can take something away from that. We are all in situations where we have to prove ourselves and where the spotlight is on us. Even if it's just the next job interview, the important meeting with a client, or at a symposium. It is worth not just trying to cast oneself in a good light and showing the golden side to the camera. One can dare to simply be oneself. Because in the end, this 'setting the stage' is exposed as incredible faster than one would like. In the age of social media, embodying authenticity instead of playing a role is a must. It should encourage us that in professional life, it is not about copying someone, but about remembering one's own identity. You don't have to be a charismatic entertainer to build authority with employees or lead a company. We rather need to turn our authentic DNA outward. Whether as a CEO, a department head, or a normal employee. However, a little more emotionality than Scholz certainly wouldn't hurt. Truly emotional people will be the leaders of tomorrow. Interpersonal skills are what count. Artificial intelligence handles everything else.
Scholz has positioned himself well. What can we learn from that?
Everyone should ask themselves: What feeling actually remains after an encounter with me? Is it a different feeling every day? For Scholz, it is respect. For Obama, it was the belief in feasibility, embodied in the positive motto 'Yes we can'. What do I want to stand for? Security or inspiration? It is important to be able to tell people in one sentence what drives me. No one is actually interested in what is on my business card or CV. An example: Two applicants for a job are equally well-qualified on paper. But one could clearly say in the interview what drives him, what he stands for. Then that is the factor that decides success.
This election campaign seemed more American than ever because of its sharpness and attacks. Isn't it surprising then that with Olaf Scholz, the prototype of the German is ahead?
The one who tries the least to set himself up as a hero receives the greatest voter favor. (...) A campaign of Markus Söder against Robert Habeck would have given us a campaign of stances, a fight of real personalities. Instead, we are discussing messed-up CVs and a weak laugh in the flood zone.
The interview with Christopher Spall was conducted by Marcel Reich.
Image source: Bild von Goumbik auf Pixabay