The 5 Distinctive Brand Lessons of 2023

What remains of this year from a branding perspective?
1. Meteoric Rise:
How Udo Lindenberg Teaches Us Consistency
The year is 1973, specifically August 13th. 27-year-old Udo Lindenberg drafts his master plan on a napkin. His goal: To become the biggest rock star. A selection of his measures: Always perform with a hat, with at least 1.2 per mille alcohol in his system on stage, and renaming his band the Panik-Orchester. By December of that same year, the "Panic Rocker" achieves his breakthrough with the album "Alles klar auf der Andrea Doria." Over 100,000 records sold and number 23 in the charts.
50 years later. At the age of 77, Udo Lindenberg lands the first No. 1 hit of his career. The song "Komet," a duet with rapper Apache 207, climbs to number 1 in the charts—and stays there for 21 weeks. A record.
What do we learn from this?
Strong brands are not created overnight. Brand building takes time and, above all, one thing: perseverance. Udo Lindenberg has managed to remain highly relevant for over 50 years. Not by reinventing himself every few years, but by staying true to his style. So, dare to maintain a clear line with your brand and experience the appreciation you deserve. In doing so, it is helpful to put your own strategy on paper. Even a napkin is enough for that...
Suppose you want to damage a brand step by step—how would you go about it? Sometimes it feels as if Deutsche Bahn is actually asking itself this very question. This year was a record year for the state-owned corporation: never before have so many trains been unpunctual. The low point of its reputation seems to have been reached. Time to investigate how one actually manages to build such a poor reputation. How does it work? Here is our tongue-in-cheek guide to destroying your own reputation:
2. In Three Moves to Germany's Most Unpopular Brand: Deutsche Bahn
Ensure that there is no competition.
Competition is tedious. It costs money and energy. It constantly forces us to improve. That’s annoying. Without it, we don't have to try anymore. We can let ourselves go a bit. After all, what are customers supposed to do if there is no alternative on the market? Just don't do it like they do in Norway. There, multiple rail service providers exist that try to outdo each other in terms of performance. Everything there runs digitally and smoothly. But until that point is reached, a lot of work would be required. That’s just too much stress. Cool down.
Get the state on board.
Obtain state participation so that in the future, you have many decision-makers from outside the industry sitting at the table who, out of fear for their positions, take no risks. This ensures that as little as possible changes. And you have more time again for the important things in life.
Undermine your core brand promise.
Deutsche Bahn's promise is "The time belongs to you." While others are stuck in traffic on the autobahn, your customers sit relaxed on the train watching Netflix. Wait. Stop. It would be boring to fulfill this prejudice. And do you know the slogan "Die Bahn kommt" (The train is coming)? Deutsche Bahn has led this one to absurdity as well. Increasingly, it doesn't come. So it should be "The train probably won't come."
Do as Deutsche Bahn does and counteract your promise. Leave your customers in the dark about what the experience with your brand will be like. This makes people engage with you again. You are the talk of the town. Something you can count on. Just ask the DB board.
What do we learn from this?
Catapulting a reputation into the absolute abyss is not that easy. Several consistent steps are necessary until your carefully earned credit with customers is completely squandered. Want to give it a try?
3. The Wagenknecht Calculus: Escaping Comparability or When the Person Makes the Agenda Irrelevant.
New year, new party. In the coming year, the party landscape in Germany will continue to change: Sahra Wagenknecht's "Alliance for Reason and Justice" is transforming from an association into a political party.
The party-to-be relies entirely on the charisma of the personality Sahra Wagenknecht. The former Left Party politician fills the identification vacuum currently created by Scholz, Habeck, and others. The last time a party was built around a person was in 2009—perhaps less seriously: the Horst Schlämmer Party (HSP). In a Stern poll, it achieved 18 percent approval. The new Wagenknecht party is also already receiving great support. According to the polling institutes Forsa and Kantar, a potential Wagenknecht party reaches 19 percent—1 percent more than the HSP!
Another parallel: The HSP, like the new Wagenknecht party, could not be assigned to any specific spectrum. Quote Horst Schlämmer: "We are conservative, liberal, and left-wing." What was satire for Kerkeling is strategy for Wagenknecht. This makes the Sahra Wagenknecht party the first brand in the German political spectrum that cannot be assigned a clear political direction. This makes Wagenknecht relevant for everyone who cannot identify with any of the established parties. Consequently, the party brand becomes unique. Given the current political disillusionment, this could work.
In any case, the supporters around Ms. Wagenknecht have not yet published a party program.
It will be exciting to see how the mixture of identification with the person Wagenknecht on one hand and general disillusionment regarding established parties on the other will affect future election results.
What do we learn from this?
People want to identify with people, not with abstract constructs.
This phenomenon works not only in politics but also in business. Studies show that almost half of a company's reputation is attributed to the CEO (https://webershandwick.com). And yet, many CEOs and managing directors prefer to stay under the radar—and waste enormous potential. Not only do customers want to know who is at the top on the other side and what stance that person represents. It is also becoming increasingly relevant for applicants to find out more about their potential employer. If they then find an empty profile on LinkedIn, perhaps even without a photo, things get thin.
Our clear recommendation: Get your stance to the point and become present. Strengthen your brand's reputation with the charisma of your personality. Unless you are Elon Musk, then maybe a little less presence wouldn't be so bad...
4. Brand Experiment MediaMarkt and SATURN: How to Turn Two Strong Brands into One.
For 33 years now, the two specialist retailers have belonged to the Metro Group (Ceconomy) and do pretty much exactly the same thing. They offer the same products, the same services, and even the same prices. Combined, there are nearly 400 stores in Germany. Some with the brand color black, others with red. We are, of course, talking about MediaMarkt and SATURN. Both brands hitherto had their own presence, their own campaigns, and their own brand slogan. Running two brands in a tough online price war made no sense under these conditions. The decision-makers have now recognized this and, for the first time in 2023, began running joint advertising campaigns. A joint logo can now be found on the websites of both brands, and the layout of the pages is identical. Only the different brand colors have remained. This makes one wonder how long the parent company Ceconomy will maintain this constellation.
What do we learn from this?
There are many brands in the world. Far too many. Studies show that 75 percent of brands worldwide could disappear and simply be replaced by an equivalent brand—without anyone noticing! (Havas Meaningful Brands report 2021)
This year, for example, the fruit juice brand Punica was taken off the market, despite having been around since the 1970s. Did you notice?
So, if you manage several brands or product brands whose services, target groups, and positioning are very similar or even identical, you should take a closer look. After all, managing brands is known to cost a lot of money and can make profiling more difficult. If you decide to merge your brands, you don't have to do it in one step. Let's not forget what brands are essentially there for: to provide security and orientation.
We are convinced that the current brand strategy at MediaMarkt SATURN is only an intermediate step. In recent years, more and more SATURN stores have become MediaMarkts after renovations. Overall, today just over 30 percent of the group's 400 German stores are "SATURN."
With joint campaigns and an identical web presence, Ceconomy is thus getting customers used to the new reality step by step. In a few years, only one brand will remain. And that will most likely be the stronger individual brand: MediaMarkt. Want to bet?
5. Fewer Steering Wheel Variants for More Brand Strength: How Opel is Working on a Comeback After 10 Years in the Red.
The traditional German carmaker Opel is an example of the fact that awareness and attractiveness are two different things. Everyone knows the brand, but hardly anyone wants to drive it. For years, it failed to build a clear profile. A symbol of the lack of direction was also the selection of extras. The Vice Head of Communications put it something like this: "For the Insignia, for example, we had over 20 steering wheel variants. You can imagine how packed our factories were. And we had so many colors that virtually no car existed twice."
In contrast, the annual financial statements knew only one color: red. The missing Opel DNA opened the floodgates for creativity. The brand became arbitrary. Without clear positioning, the carmaker racked up an incredible 19 years of losses in a row. On average, 1 billion in losses per year.
In 2018, as part of Stellantis, Opel managed to climb back into the black. The core of the strategy: radically reducing the variety of options and focusing clearly on small and mid-sized cars—of course with a high share of electrification. Even the Insignia sedan was cut—for the time being, at least.
What do we learn from this?
Fewer choices, a clear focus on a specific positioning for services—strong brands create a clear image in people's minds. They don't offer everything to everyone. They concentrate their energy before the brand becomes too nebulous. They dare to leave out what doesn't fit their own identity. Sounds simple in theory—but requires courage. Dare to say "no" and focus clearly on what really suits you. This saves resources and ensures a clear image—and thus attractiveness.
We will see if Opel stays true to the new line. The results of recent years give cause for hope. The medicine is starting to work.
The strongest brand lies within yourself.
That's why our conclusion for 2023 remains the same as for 2022:
Develop identity. Embody attractiveness.
Image source: Image by Danilo Carta from Pixabay