The 5 Distinctive Brand Lessons of 2022

What remains from this year from a brand perspective?
1. The Musk Lottery: Will Twitter's Cough Become Pneumonia for Tesla & Co?
Elon Musk was omnipresent again in 2022. However, not in his usual strong roles as a visionary, doer, and driver of momentum, but as the manager of his latest acquisition: Twitter. There, the Tesla and SpaceX boss first cleared house vigorously. Not even coffee machines and office furniture were safe from his radical cuts. But things are not going as usual for the South African, who has been spoiled by success lately. Suddenly, the eccentric multibillionaire is facing headwinds. Recently, he was even booed for several minutes during his surprise appearance at comedian Dave Chappelle's show. Why is that? Elon Musk is increasingly leaving the roles in which he shines. With Tesla, Musk revolutionized electromobility; with SpaceX, he flies to space for NASA; and with Starlink, he makes internet possible all over the world. This is where the innovator thrives and is like a fish in water. As a classic manager, however, as is currently the case with the short-messaging service Twitter, he seems out of place. And that is being noticed.
Musk is losing more and more support from the population and, with this loss of credibility, is also endangering his other "children." In particular, Tesla stock has lost more than 50% of its value in 2022. Musk has already drawn initial consequences. Via a poll, he let Twitter users vote on whether he should remain in the role of Twitter manager. Not surprisingly, the majority voted "No."
What do we learn from this?
CEO branding is not a Mickey Mouse discipline, but basic craft for C-level executives. In Elon Musk's case, he is currently risking the success of his Tesla brand. Few realize that about 50% of corporate reputation is attributed to the CEO. Musk acts intuitively. And he was often right. Now the lottery is swinging in the opposite direction. Effective CEO positioning and a clear understanding of roles are the keys to ending the lottery and beginning a systematic strengthening of the corporate brand(s) through the CEO. But perhaps the (second) richest person in the world simply doesn't care.
2. China's Attack on German Car Brands: How Relevant Are 130 Years of History for a Brand's Success?
BMW and Mercedes still belong to the 15 most valuable brands in the world in 2022. But what is that worth in an industry that is moving away from the internal combustion engine at high speed? A look at China, the largest car market, paints a bleak picture. This year, for example, the brand Human Horizons—completely unknown here—sold its luxury model HiPhi X more frequently than Mercedes sold the EQS. Manufacturing quality in the Far East and especially high software competence are enabling Chinese manufacturers to increasingly lure customers away from German giants in the electric luxury segment. By the way, the undisputed market leader in China for electric cars is BYD. Never heard of it? The Tang model can already be pre-ordered in Europe.
Is German engineering, like the internal combustion engine, suddenly worth nothing? Daimler has more than 130 years of experience. But since 2022, Chinese premium brands like Nio have been outperforming the inventor of the automobile in terms of performance. German manufacturers have to offer massive discounts in China to sell cars at all. Thus, the premium image of combustion engines is not transferable one-to-one to electric cars. And until now, one could still feel the difference from the Chinese competition in the interior. But those days are over. Brands like Nio operate in the same premium segment. Both design and interior are on par with traditional German brands.
We are convinced that domestic car brands can manage to turn the corner. However, this requires more than software cosmetics and new models.
What needs to be done? German premium brands must create real differentiation again. This requires a return to their own identity and its translation into the e-car world.
What do we learn from this?
Tradition alone is worthless. Only when a long history leads to concrete added value is it decisive for a purchase. Only then does it strengthen the brand. Therefore, local automotive giants should work more on concrete differentiation advantages again. Then premium prices are justified. Then BMW, Mercedes, and Audi might be able to fend off the Chinese competition. But first, there is some homework to do: the German software in the Mercedes currently does not reliably recognize voice inputs in Mandarin.
3. Adidas' Odyssey with a Racist Rapper: When Reach at Any Price Becomes a Boomerang
In October 2022, Adidas ended its 8-year cooperation with rapper Kanye West. Under the shoe brand ADIDAS YEEZY (West's nickname), the Herzogenaurach-based company at times generated over $1 billion per year. After West again made headlines with his racist and anti-Semitic stance and announced that ADIDAS could not drop him, the sporting goods manufacturer finally pulled the plug. Previously, Instagram and Twitter had already blocked the rapper's accounts, luxury manufacturer Balenciaga ended the cooperation, and JPMorgan Chase closed his accounts. West's escapades are no surprise: his career is peppered with controversial appearances and statements.
What do we learn from this?
Cooperations can be enormously lucrative for brands—but also enormously dangerous. In particular, cooperations with personalities can quickly lead to the person's characteristics being linked to the brand. Often, cooperations are intended to push a brand's awareness at any price. In the process, however, it is often forgotten that attractiveness is the more valuable currency. A well-known brand that no one wants is worthless. A highly attractive niche brand, on the other hand, can be extremely successful. As a bonus, attractive brands are recommended, which automatically generates awareness. So, if you are thinking about cooperations, make sure to select partners based on shared values and a thematic fit—not just based on fame. This way, you build long-term attractiveness for your brand and avoid shitstorms.
4. What Messi's Triumph Teaches Us: The Power of a Shared Core Purpose
The Argentine national team led by captain Lionel Messi recently proved how enormously unifying a shared core purpose can be. Despite an opening defeat against Saudi Arabia, the team did not stop believing in the shared mission: helping their national hero achieve the crowning World Cup title. A feat of strength not just for 7-time Ballon d'Or winner Messi against a France whose squad was worth nearly €400 million more on paper.
What do we learn from this?
What works in football also works for brands in business. We must become aware of the power a shared mission in the form of a clearly formulated core purpose can unleash. The answer to the question "What are we needed for?" can be more effective than any bonus or benefit. Today, core purpose should be an indispensable building block of brand identity for every brand. It doesn't matter whether your company manufactures screws or provides tax consulting. Those who want to reap identification must sow meaning.
5. Learning from Patagonia Means Daring More Radicalism
Patagonia has long been considered a prime example of the connection between sustainability and business success. This year, company founder Yvon Chouinard dared far more than the well-known 2011 advertisement "Don't buy this jacket" or the 1996 decision to produce only with organic cotton: he transferred Patagonia to a non-profit foundation. All profits that are not reinvested in the company go to the foundation to fight climate change. We are certain that this step will propel the brand's attractiveness to new heights.
One could also claim that Patagonia is successful precisely because of its radical actions. Which brings us to the origin of the word radicalism. The word comes from the Latin word Radix and translates to root. Anyone who tackles something radically is therefore dedicated to a problem at its root. In general usage, however, the adjective radical has an almost exclusively negative connotation. Not to mention "radicalization."
What do we learn from this?
Perhaps we need more radicalism in organizations and our lives—that is, more people who tackle problems at the root and consistently follow through on strategies. We see exactly this consistency, this positive radicalism, at Patagonia.
Don't worry, you don't have to hand over your brand to a foundation. But Chouinard teaches us one thing: commitment is only truly credible if it also costs something. If it seems that your commitment only serves the purpose of profit maximization, your customers will quickly notice and penalize it. So don't jump on the "1 tree per crate" bandwagon. Because in the end, your brand doesn't have to save the world.
Identify a charitable cause that fits your brand's identity and stick with it. Whether you, as a travel brand, clean selected beaches in Mallorca every year or, as a manufacturer of stationery, support a school in Kenya. Most importantly: you and your employees must stand fully behind it. Then your customers will appreciate the commitment and bond more strongly with your brand.
The strongest brand lies within yourself.
Therefore, our conclusion for 2022 remains the same as for 2021:
Develop identity. Feel attractiveness.
Image source: Image by Danilo Carta from Pixabay