CEO Scandals: What impact does the corporate leader's reputation have on the company's reputation?

50% of a company's reputation is attributed to the CEO. The CEO's reputation is therefore just as important as all of an organization's marketing activities combined. Do CEO missteps only ignite a flash in the pan? Or do they cause a major wildfire? The answer is: It depends...
In the case of a single CEO misstep, a short-term negative impact is possible - as is currently the case with Müllermilch due to Theo Müller's dinner with AfD leader Alice Weidel.
The Assessment of Reputational Risks
In the age of social media, corporate leaders are in the spotlight more than ever. Every step they take is evaluated and contributes to the organization's reputation. A curse and a blessing? On the one hand, the CEO's behavior presents a great opportunity to strengthen the reputation of a company or brand. On the other hand, how great the risk is in the event of misconduct depends on various factors.
Whether a CEO's negative headlines have only a short-term negative impact on the company or brand, or whether they cause permanent damage, is measured using our Reputation Risk Scorecard (RSC). This takes various metrics into account, e.g.:
Is it a single misstep or a systemic error?
How great is the brand equity, i.e., the leap of faith that the brand enjoys?
How great is the risk for the customer being negatively affected by the scandal themselves?
On the occasion of dairy billionaire Theo Müller's meeting with AfD leader Alice Weidel, Christopher Spall spoke in an interview with Michael Scheppe from Handelsblatt about how a CEO's actions affect brand reputation.
Conclusion in this case:
In the case of individual missteps, a short-term negative impact is possible.
When fans of the brand drink Müllermilch, they might now get the feeling that they are supporting the AfD. However, the public outcry is quickly forgotten by many people because such scandals are quickly superseded by other news.
Other prominent examples
Elon Musk & X
Elon Musk buys Twitter, changes the name and logo overnight, and fires 1,000 people.
The result: Trust is gone.
According to the New York Times, the social media company could have lost up to 75 million US dollars in advertising revenue because several large companies stopped their campaigns on X after Elon Musk's takeover.
Josef Ackermann & Deutsche Bank
CEO Josef Ackermann, charged with serious breach of trust, gives the victory sign in the courtroom.
The result: The image of the greedy banker is etched in.
The higher the symbolic power, the longer the story stays in the mind. Even after 20 years, the scandal is closely linked to the bank's reputation.
Kanye West & adidas
US rapper Kanye West exhibits anti-Semitic, racist, and sexist behavior; adidas ends the cooperation.
The result: Losses in the billions due to unsold products.
Due to years of successful collaboration and great popularity, there is a particularly close link with high visibility. The sporting goods manufacturer has not yet recovered from this.
Moral vs. economic arguments
If unpopular decisions are made by corporate management, a differentiated view is worthwhile - as in the example of the medium-sized family business Ritter Sport.
Ritter Sport
Despite the Russian war of aggression against Ukraine, chocolate manufacturer Ritter Sport continues to deliver its chocolate to Russia.
The result: A shitstorm on social media.
Stopping deliveries would have had an impact on production. This in turn would have jeopardized jobs, especially those of Russian sales employees. Responsibility towards dependent cocoa farmers is also cited as a reason for continuing business. However, investments and advertising in Russia were stopped. The argument becomes credible primarily through the fact that the profits from the Russia business – approx. 1.5 million euros (as of the end of 2022) – were donated.
Opportunity for medium-sized businesses
Crucially: If the CEO's activities and the organization's values are consistent, a reputation bonus can be built up. If the behavior of the person in charge and the company's values diverge, the bonus can quickly turn into a malus.
In particular, there is an untapped opportunity here for German medium-sized businesses. Many corporate leaders in this country prefer to stay behind the scenes - and thus give away a lot of potential. Because the CEO can certainly influence the company's reputation very effectively in a positive sense.
The impact of corporate activism on sales figures
Brands are made by people.
Image source: Foto von Anita Jankovic auf Unsplash